Navigator, astronomer testify at TMT hearing (HI TRIBUNE HERALD)

Hawaii Tribune-Herald


Baybayan is a captain in the Polynesian Voyaging Society and was awarded the rank of pwo, a degree in the Weriyeng School of Navigation of Micronesia, by his teacher Mau Piailug, the master navigator who guided the first voyage of Hokulea.

He previously was the navigator-in-residence and an assistant director for ‘Imiloa Astronomy Center, which is part of the university, and said his opinion presented during testimony “is my own and does not represent any of my organizations.”

During cross-examination, he said he thinks TMT and Hawaiian cultural practices could co-exist.

“I’m a modern Hawaiian. I believe in my traditions, I believe in my culture, but I think that’s consistent with our progression … to be highly reflective and highly motivated to learn about the world we live in, and so we ally ourselves with the tradition of curiosity and exploration,” he said.

Other parties questioned Baybayan about his own cultural practices and what Mauna Kea meant to him as a navigator. One party, Chase Kahookahi Kanuha, asked how many Hawaiian astronomers were working on Mauna Kea. Baybayan named one astronomer.

Kanuha then asked how Hawaiians would benefit from the TMT if “less than 0.0001 percent had direct participation in the telescopes.”

“What legitimate participation have Hawaiians had in this field of science through telescopes on Mauna Kea other than the giving of their sacred mauna for desecration in the name of astronomy and giant telescopes?” he said.

Baybayan said people did not need to be directly observing at the telescope sites in order to participate, and that technicians and those who use astronomy data once it is collected also could benefit from the project.

McLaren, the associate director for the University of Hawaii at Manoa Institute for Astronomy, was cross-examined by just one party, Deborah Ward, before the end of the day. He was asked primarily about costs of telescope decommissioning and liability.

The contested case is a quasi-judicial hearing and is the second TMT-related contested case in the past six years. The first case began in 2011. The state Board of Land and Natural Resources issued a permit to UH to build the $1.4 billion telescope before that case concluded.

In December 2015, the state Supreme Court said that permit was not valid because its issuance violated due process of those in the contested case. Pre-hearing conferences for the new case began in June.

All hearings take place from 9 a.m-4:30 p.m. at the Hilo Naniloa Hotel Crown Room.

Hearings are scheduled for Nov. 15-16, Nov. 18, Nov. 21-23, Nov. 28, Dec. 1-2, Dec. 5-6, Dec. 8-9, Dec. 12-13, Dec. 16 and Dec. 19-20.


We humbly ask, knowing that we are one among many who need kokua being here. We humbly ask you consider supporting all of us. We humbly ask that if you feel the burial rights of all humans are paramount- if you feel that a 20 story atrocity with 15,000 gallons of wastes stored underground is wrong in an endangered species environment and you want it to be stopped. Please considers and share our crowdfuding. We cannot do this without you:


Find archived updates at

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s